Back to Reality

I was at my annual boys golf tournament the past 3 days. We call it "Party At The Pines" at a resort in northern Minnesota. This is the 14th year we have gone north with 16 or 20 guys and played non-stop golf for 3 days. It is a great way to get away from it all. You can't think stocks or trouble at work, when you are focused on hitting that little white ball about 400 times over those 3 days.

Now that I have missed all the stock market fun this week, I have a little chance to consider what has happened and where we go from here. One thing is for sure, the market has left its moorings. It has entered the irrational phase when anything can happen. The one thing I know from all the reading I have done, is that at times like this, it is best to just stand still and do nothing.

I am not a disinterested bystander, by the way. I thought I was fairly well protected from this eruption (which I suggested was a possibility as early as 2005, based on the housing bubble bursting), but I have been more or less fully invested since I believe it is impossible to pick a bottom. And honestly, this market situation is at the extreme end of what I thought was possible. There has always been a doomsday scenario suggested by some analysts, that would be triggered by this type of loss of confidence in the financial system. But I never really thought it would go as far as it has.

You know that I have been buying high dividend stocks and funds and reinvesting the large dividends in the same stocks to average down my cost if the price goes lower. I am very diverse in my holdings so that the risk is spread. But still I am getting hurt badly in this market because even the babies are now getting thrown out. Even cash is no longer safe, as some big money market funds are now "breaking the buck" and unable to return $1 of principal.

But this has all the look of capitulation. VIX peaked at near 40 today, which is its highest level since the 2000-03. Generally any spike over 30 signals fear in the market and a buying opportunity, though note how long high market volatility went on in the Tech Bust:



What needs to happen to change the direction of the market? There are a few basic actions to look for. The basic need is to break the vicious feedback loop in which the market is now engaged. The actions need to come from the government as they are regulatory in nature and in most instances, the government initiated the rules or regulations that have precipitated this crisis.

1. Suspend the "Mark-to-Market" rule: It came out of Sarbanes-Oxley legislation and was implented by the accounting board, FASB. Mark to Market is the primary culprit for circular market action, since the action of marking down assets weakens the capital structure of a bank and causes it to decline in value. As assets decline in value based on the weakness in the institutions backing the financial assets, the market price declines requiring another round of markdowns. This has gone on until some banks have broken their statutory capital requirement level and become insolvent in the process. This must stop to repair the market, so look for a loosening here and the option of "Marking to Model"

2. Clamp down on short selling: Although I have been doing some short selling to provide protection, and believe in it from a free market perspective, but it can really exacerbate the snowball effect of a downward spiraling market. Because financial institutions use the equity on their balance sheet as capital against their book of bank financing, they are exposed to damage by short selling more than other businesses which don't leverage their equity to do business. The "uptick" rule should be reinstated and I see that there are further restrictions on Market Makers put into effect by the SEC today so that shorts have to have claim to the physical stock in order to short it (that is, no naked shorts).

3. Continue infusing liquidity into the market: The Feds need to continue flooding the market with capital so that the financial engine does not seize up. Money is like a lubricant to financial institutions and business in general. If it ever stops flowing, then business freezes. The Feds have many ways to put money back into the financial markets.

4. Back more institutions with capital as needed: AIG and Fannie/Freddie were both bailed out with large US government loans. But these are not necessarily bailouts that will cost the taxpayer over the long term. This is the modern equivalent of the Resolution Trust Corp (RTC). The Feds are giving capital loans at a high percent interest ($85B at 12% in the case of AIG). This paper can later be sold on the open market at a big profit once the market panic passes and the company's balance sheet is repaired, just as any bond can be sold.

Goldman Sachs (GS) and Morgan Stanley now look like the two that need the most help, though they were thought to be top of the heap a few weeks ago. GS just beat expectations with its earnings report on Tuesday. Apparently their CDSs (credit default swaps which are like loan insurance) sold to other banks to hedge risk in loan portfolios, are jumping in cost. The Fed can help them here by buying the CDSs onto the Fed's balance sheet and later reselling to the market at a profit, to the taxpayer's benefit.

Even though they have so far avoided attack by the short sellers, USB and Wells Fargo are not out of the woods. In this market, the shorts can ruin any bank.

5. Coordinate Central Banks globally to take a similar approach with their own national banking companies. There is so much linkage in the financial system this is not an exclusively American problem, though it may have started here. The Central Bankers should be talking to each other (I am sure they are) to coordinate actions for the maximum positive effect. The Euro can be used to prop up European banks and the Chinese and Japanese central banks are flush and should do the same for their home banks.

6. The Central Bank should not worry about inflation right now. Everything happening right now (not 6 months ago) is Deflationary, not Inflationary. Financial contraction, in terms of deleveraging of financial institutions and dropping real estate prices, is inherently deflationary. The Fed can pump as much money into the banking system as it wants without adverse effects today. Once there is recovery, the Fed then would need to take money back out of the financial system by calling its loans, or selling them off.

7. Shut down the ratings agencies: Moody's, S&P, and other ratings agencies are doing more harm than good. They were big contributors in blowing up the real estate bubble by rating sub-prime securities as AAA, thereby attracting cheap money from abroad into our housing market. And now they are over-reacting the other direction and are dropping ratings on good companies because their stock price is declining and it is decreasing capital ratio coverage (see points 3 and 4). The function of agencies is to provide constructive guidance to investors based on their research departments. But the agencies have not lived up to that promise for more than a decade. They missed the Tech Bust as well.


8. Finally, remember that when the market does get over its panic, the rebound will be substantial. It may not bounce back to 14,000 Dow anytime soon, but it could bounce back to 12,500. The Financials that are left standing can double or triple over a 6-12 month period as they regain the irrational / non-fundamental losses. So, financial index UYG, as one suggestion, will do very well at some point.

I hope Bernanke and Paulsen work quickly on the above, plus anything else they can think of that I have not. They need to do so to keep us from crashing into a Depression. I think we have the right people at the top to avoid a real crash with Bernanke an expert on deflations and Paulsen an expert on investment banking finance. Watch for any or all the above and when you see action taken, it should solve the problem.

Until I see what comes from the Fed, I am sitting on my hands trying to avoid doing any more damage to my accounts by selling low, but also not sure if we are at the bottom, so not willing to buy, other than through the methodical reinvestment of dividends that I have set up.